# Watch it work: one household, every call to the calculator, and the answer.

Source: https://plannerbench.org/replay.html · plain-text twin of that page, made from it at build time · all pages: https://plannerbench.org/llms.txt

Replays

In short

These are the whole-household decisions from [With a calculator](https://plannerbench.org/calculator.html#gauntlet). Each replay starts with the household and the choice it faces, then shows how the model did against the answer key, then every step: what it asked the calculator (the planning engine), what came back, and any question it put to the client. Where the same model also answered on its own, both answers sit side by side. Pick another question or model below.

Question How much to convert to a Roth, and for how many years Model DeepSeek V4.1 Flash (Oct 17) with the calculator

The household

## How much to convert to a Roth, and for how many years

Ray and Linda want to start Roth conversions from Ray's traditional IRA this year and want to know how much to convert.

What the model was told

- Married, filing jointly.
- They live in a state with no income tax.
- Ray: born February 1957 (turns 69 in 2026). Enrolled in Medicare Part B and a Part D drug plan (or will be from age 65). Already receiving Social Security: $3,460 a month as of January 2026 (claimed at full retirement age).
- Linda: born September 1959 (turns 67 in 2026). Enrolled in Medicare Part B and a Part D drug plan (or will be from age 65). Already receiving Social Security: $1,180 a month as of January 2026 (claimed at full retirement age).
- Ray's traditional IRA: $1,600,000 on December 31, 2025. Includes $208,000 of after-tax (nondeductible) contributions (Form 8606 basis).
- Linda's traditional IRA: $60,000 on December 31, 2025. All pre-tax (no after-tax basis).
- Ray's Roth IRA: $75,000 on December 31, 2025. First Roth contribution in 2014.
- Linda's Roth IRA: $45,000 on December 31, 2025. First Roth contribution in 2016.
- Joint savings (cash) account: $440,000 on December 31, 2025.
- Ray's pension (fully taxable): $11,000 a year from 2026, no raises.
- Linda's taxable interest: $9,000 a year from 2026, no raises.
- Ray's tax-exempt municipal bond interest: $6,000 a year from 2026, no raises.
- Spending: $92,000 a year after tax in 2026 dollars, rising with inflation. Federal tax and Medicare premiums are paid on top of this.
- Paid out of that spending each year (2026 dollars, rising with inflation): property tax $4,500. No other deductible expenses.
- Their 2024 MAGI (for Medicare IRMAA) was $104,000, on a joint return.
- Their 2025 MAGI (for Medicare IRMAA) was $150,000, on a joint return.

MAGI and IRMAA: Medicare sets premiums from income two years earlier (MAGI); higher income adds a surcharge (IRMAA). After-tax basis (Form 8606): money already taxed, so it isn’t taxed again when it comes out. Muni interest: interest from state or city bonds; free of federal tax, but it still counts in the income Medicare uses for premiums.

The choice

Find the best plan: the same amount converted every year, for 1 to 10 years starting in 2026, any amount. “Best” means the most after-tax wealth; if no conversion is best, say 0. The two plans below aren’t the choices; they are only there to price the other numbers it had to give.

- **A.** No Roth conversion.
- **P.** Convert $155,000 from Ray's traditional IRA to Ray's Roth IRA in 2026 only.

It also had to give these numbers

1. If they converted $155,000 in 2026 only, how much more federal income tax would they owe for 2026 than with no conversion?
2. If they converted $155,000 in 2026 only, how much more would they pay in Medicare premiums for 2028 than with no conversion (Part B plus Part D surcharges, both spouses, all 12 months)?

How it did

Fully right

**DeepSeek V4.1 Flash (Oct 17) with the calculator.** Right decision, and every number within 2% of the key.

Not fully right

**DeepSeek V4.1 Flash (Oct 17) on its own.** Wrong plan. That's a projected $134,445 less after-tax wealth over 25 years (a simulation, not a real household).

|  | Right answer | With the calculator | On its own |
|---|---|---|---|
| The decision | $118,000 a year × 8 years | ✓ $118,000 a year × 8 years | ✗ Convert nothing |
| If they converted $155,000 in 2026 only, how much more federal income tax would they owe for 2026 than with no conversion? | $27,676 | ✓ $27,676 | ✓ $27,835 |
| If they converted $155,000 in 2026 only, how much more would they pay in Medicare premiums for 2028 than with no conversion (Part B plus Part D surcharges, both spouses, all 12 months)? | $2,412 | ✓ $2,412 | ✓ $2,412 |

How it got there

3 calls to the calculator, in order. Cost 1¢.

1. 1
   
   ### Searched for the best Roth conversion `solve_roth_conversion`
   
   What it sent
   
   - **Household**: Ray, Linda: 5 accounts, 3 income sources
   - **Convert from**: ray_ira
   - **Up to**: 10 years
   
   What the calculator said
   
   Convert about $118,000 a year for 8 years (2026–2033): +$134,445 after-tax wealth at the end, in today's dollars.
   
   The engine tried 1,373 plans to find it.
   
   The calculator also suggested asking: “What tax bracket are the kids or other heirs likely to be in?”
   
   **Show the raw call**
   
   Sent
   
   ```
   {
    "household": {
     "filing": "mfj",
     "state": "none",
     "people": [
      {
       "id": "Ray",
       "born": 1957,
       "born_month": 2,
       "medicare": true,
       "social_security": {
        "monthly_at_fra": 3460,
        "claim_age": 66.5,
        "already_claimed_monthly": 3460,
        "claimed_at_months": 798
       }
      },
      {
       "id": "Linda",
       "born": 1959,
       "born_month": 9,
       "medicare": true,
       "social_security": {
        "monthly_at_fra": 1180,
        "claim_age": 66.833333,
        "already_claimed_monthly": 1180,
        "claimed_at_months": 802
       }
      }
     ],
     "accounts": [
      {
       "id": "ray_ira",
       "owner": "Ray",
       "type": "traditional_ira",
       "balance": 1600000,
       "after_tax_basis": 208000
      },
      {
       "id": "linda_ira",
       "owner": "Linda",
       "type": "traditional_ira",
       "balance": 60000
      },
      {
       "id": "ray_roth",
       "owner": "Ray",
       "type": "roth_ira",
       "balance": 75000,
       "first_roth_year": 2014
      },
      {
       "id": "linda_roth",
       "owner": "Linda",
       "type": "roth_ira",
       "balance": 45000,
       "first_roth_year": 2016
      },
      {
       "id": "cash",
       "owner": "joint",
       "type": "cash",
       "balance": 440000
      }
     ],
     "income": [
      {
       "type": "pension",
       "owner": "Ray",
       "annual": 11000,
       "start_year": 2026
      },
      {
       "type": "interest_taxable",
       "owner": "Linda",
       "annual": 9000,
       "start_year": 2026
      },
      {
       "type": "interest_tax_exempt",
       "owner": "Ray",
       "annual": 6000,
       "start_year": 2026
      }
     ],
     "spending_need": 92000,
     "itemized": {
      "salt_other": 4500
     },
     "prior_magi": {
      "2024": {
       "magi": 104000,
       "filing": "mfj"
      },
      "2025": {
       "magi": 150000,
       "filing": "mfj"
      }
     }
    },
    "from": "ray_ira",
    "max_years": 10,
    "assumptions": {
     "first_year": 2026,
     "last_year": 2050,
     "return": 0.05,
     "inflation": 0.025,
     "heirs_tax_rate": 0.12
    }
   }
   ```
2. 2
   
   ### Ran 2 options year by year, 2026–2050 `run_scenario`
   
   What it sent
   
   - **Household**: Ray, Linda: 5 accounts, 3 income sources
   - **Options to compare**: 2
   - **Assumed return**: 5% a year
   
   What the calculator said
   
   |  |  |  |
   |---|---|---|
   | Convert 155000 in 2026 only best | $2,743,381 |  |
   | Do nothing | $2,712,728 | −$30,653 |
   
   After-tax wealth left in 2050, in today's dollars. Higher is better.
   
   The calculator also suggested asking: “What tax bracket are the kids or other heirs likely to be in?”
   
   **Show the raw call**
   
   Sent
   
   ```
   {
    "household": {
     "filing": "mfj",
     "state": "none",
     "people": [
      {
       "id": "Ray",
       "born": 1957,
       "born_month": 2,
       "medicare": true,
       "social_security": {
        "monthly_at_fra": 3460,
        "claim_age": 66.5,
        "already_claimed_monthly": 3460,
        "claimed_at_months": 798
       }
      },
      {
       "id": "Linda",
       "born": 1959,
       "born_month": 9,
       "medicare": true,
       "social_security": {
        "monthly_at_fra": 1180,
        "claim_age": 66.833333,
        "already_claimed_monthly": 1180,
        "claimed_at_months": 802
       }
      }
     ],
     "accounts": [
      {
       "id": "ray_ira",
       "owner": "Ray",
       "type": "traditional_ira",
       "balance": 1600000,
       "after_tax_basis": 208000
      },
      {
       "id": "linda_ira",
       "owner": "Linda",
       "type": "traditional_ira",
       "balance": 60000
      },
      {
       "id": "ray_roth",
       "owner": "Ray",
       "type": "roth_ira",
       "balance": 75000,
       "first_roth_year": 2014
      },
      {
       "id": "linda_roth",
       "owner": "Linda",
       "type": "roth_ira",
       "balance": 45000,
       "first_roth_year": 2016
      },
      {
       "id": "cash",
       "owner": "joint",
       "type": "cash",
       "balance": 440000
      }
     ],
     "income": [
      {
       "type": "pension",
       "owner": "Ray",
       "annual": 11000,
       "start_year": 2026
      },
      {
       "type": "interest_taxable",
       "owner": "Linda",
       "annual": 9000,
       "start_year": 2026
      },
      {
       "type": "interest_tax_exempt",
       "owner": "Ray",
       "annual": 6000,
       "start_year": 2026
      }
     ],
     "spending_need": 92000,
     "itemized": {
      "salt_other": 4500
     },
     "prior_magi": {
      "2024": {
       "magi": 104000,
       "filing": "mfj"
      },
      "2025": {
       "magi": 150000,
       "filing": "mfj"
      }
     }
    },
    "plans": [
     {
      "name": "Do nothing",
      "actions": []
     },
     {
      "name": "Convert 155000 in 2026 only",
      "actions": [
       {
        "type": "roth_conversion",
        "from": "ray_ira",
        "amount": 155000,
        "years": [
         2026
        ]
       }
      ]
     }
    ],
    "assumptions": {
     "first_year": 2026,
     "last_year": 2050,
     "return": 0.05,
     "inflation": 0.025,
     "heirs_tax_rate": 0.12
    }
   }
   ```
3. 3
   
   ### Ran 6 options year by year, 2026–2050 `run_scenario`
   
   What it sent
   
   - **Household**: Ray, Linda: 5 accounts, 3 income sources
   - **Options to compare**: 6
   - **Assumed return**: 5% a year
   
   What the calculator said
   
   |  |  |  |
   |---|---|---|
   | 118k x 8 best | $2,847,173 |  |
   | 105k x 10 | $2,845,358 | −$1,815 |
   | 110k x 8 | $2,844,992 | −$2,181 |
   | 120k x 8 | $2,844,209 | −$2,964 |
   | 153k x 6 | $2,838,639 | −$8,534 |
   | Do nothing | $2,712,728 | −$134,445 |
   
   After-tax wealth left in 2050, in today's dollars. Higher is better.
   
   The calculator also suggested asking: “What tax bracket are the kids or other heirs likely to be in?”
   
   **Show the raw call**
   
   Sent
   
   ```
   {
    "assumptions": {
     "first_year": 2026,
     "heirs_tax_rate": 0.12,
     "inflation": 0.025,
     "last_year": 2050,
     "return": 0.05
    },
    "household": {
     "accounts": [
      {
       "after_tax_basis": 208000,
       "balance": 1600000,
       "id": "ray_ira",
       "owner": "Ray",
       "type": "traditional_ira"
      },
      {
       "balance": 60000,
       "id": "linda_ira",
       "owner": "Linda",
       "type": "traditional_ira"
      },
      {
       "balance": 75000,
       "first_roth_year": 2014,
       "id": "ray_roth",
       "owner": "Ray",
       "type": "roth_ira"
      },
      {
       "balance": 45000,
       "first_roth_year": 2016,
       "id": "linda_roth",
       "owner": "Linda",
       "type": "roth_ira"
      },
      {
       "balance": 440000,
       "id": "cash",
       "owner": "joint",
       "type": "cash"
      }
     ],
     "filing": "mfj",
     "income": [
      {
       "annual": 11000,
       "owner": "Ray",
       "start_year": 2026,
       "type": "pension"
      },
      {
       "annual": 9000,
       "owner": "Linda",
       "start_year": 2026,
       "type": "interest_taxable"
      },
      {
       "annual": 6000,
       "owner": "Ray",
       "start_year": 2026,
       "type": "interest_tax_exempt"
      }
     ],
     "itemized": {
      "salt_other": 4500
     },
     "people": [
      {
       "born": 1957,
       "born_month": 2,
       "id": "Ray",
       "medicare": true,
       "social_security": {
        "already_claimed_monthly": 3460,
        "claim_age": 66.5,
        "claimed_at_months": 798,
        "monthly_at_fra": 3460
       }
      },
      {
       "born": 1959,
       "born_month": 9,
       "id": "Linda",
       "medicare": true,
       "social_security": {
        "already_claimed_monthly": 1180,
        "claim_age": 66.833333,
        "claimed_at_months": 802,
        "monthly_at_fra": 1180
       }
      }
     ],
     "prior_magi": {
      "2024": {
       "filing": "mfj",
       "magi": 104000
      },
      "2025": {
       "filing": "mfj",
       "magi": 150000
      }
     },
     "spending_need": 92000,
     "state": "none"
    },
    "plans": [
     {
      "actions": [],
      "name": "Do nothing"
     },
     {
      "actions": [
       {
        "amount": 118000,
        "from": "ray_ira",
        "type": "roth_conversion",
        "years": [
         2026,
         2027,
         2028,
         2029,
         2030,
         2031,
         2032,
         2033
        ]
       }
      ],
      "name": "118k x 8"
     },
     {
      "actions": [
       {
        "amount": 110000,
        "from": "ray_ira",
        "type": "roth_conversion",
        "years": [
         2026,
         2027,
         2028,
         2029,
         2030,
         2031,
         2032,
         2033
        ]
       }
      ],
      "name": "110k x 8"
     },
     {
      "actions": [
       {
        "amount": 120000,
        "from": "ray_ira",
        "type": "roth_conversion",
        "years": [
         2026,
         2027,
         2028,
         2029,
         2030,
         2031,
         2032,
         2033
        ]
       }
      ],
      "name": "120k x 8"
     },
     {
      "actions": [
       {
        "amount": 105000,
        "from": "ray_ira",
        "type": "roth_conversion",
        "years": [
         2026,
         2027,
         2028,
         2029,
         2030,
         2031,
         2032,
         2033,
         2034,
         2035
        ]
       }
      ],
      "name": "105k x 10"
     },
     {
      "actions": [
       {
        "amount": 153000,
        "from": "ray_ira",
        "type": "roth_conversion",
        "years": [
         2026,
         2027,
         2028,
         2029,
         2030,
         2031
        ]
       }
      ],
      "name": "153k x 6"
     }
    ]
   }
   ```

[Back **With a calculator: the experiments these replays come from**](https://plannerbench.org/calculator.html#gauntlet)

---

PlannerBench · 2026 rules · [For AI labs](https://plannerbench.org/labs.html) · [For financial firms](https://plannerbench.org/firms.html) · [Report](https://plannerbench.org/report.html) · [Demo walkthrough](https://plannerbench.org/chat.html) · [Replays](https://plannerbench.org/replay.html) · [peytonthalman.com](https://peytonthalman.com)

Human | For AI readers, top right: the same site as plain text for AI agents reading on someone’s behalf, with every page as Markdown.

Decision support, not advice. Answers follow IRS, SSA and CMS publications; nothing here is tax or investment advice.
